home | about | magazines | articles | news | order form | links | site history

 

Dirty Medicine

by

Martin J Walker

 


Contents list

 

PART ONE

THE STANDING ARMIES OF SCIENCE: AMERICA

Part One examines the growth of scientific medicine in America, its early battles with homoeopathy and the origins of the American Medical Association. It describes the interaction between government agencies, industry, science and health, then looks at the roles of three organizations. The American National Council Against Health Fraud is an extra-governmental agency which works with industry-connected government agencies like the Food and Drugs Administration. The American Council on Science and Health is an industry funded organization which publishes pro-industry reports on health risks. The Committee for Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal (CSICOP), is a pro-industry group which lobbies for science and campaigns against alternative medicine.

Chapter 1 The American origins of scientific medicine

Chapter 2 The beginning of the health fraud movement

Chapter 3 The American National Council Against Health Fraud

Chapter 4 Selling science and industry in America:
The American Council on Science and Health

Chapter 5 The rational idea in a materialist world:
Committee for Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal
 



PART TWO

THE INSURGENTS BEFORE 1989

Part Two looks at the early careers and work of a number of people from different disciplines involved in health care. They are all involved in innovative non-orthodox work, which has brought them under severe scrutiny and critical attack from those with vested interests in science, government or industry. Dr Jacques Benveniste is a French biologist, whose experiments with high dilution substances came under critical attack in 1988. Dr William Rea is an American pioneer in the field of illness created by toxic environments, work for which he has been frequently attacked. The British practitioners introduced in this part of the book were all attacked by the Campaign Against Health Fraud after it was set up in 1989. The detailed stories of these attacks continues in Part Five of the book.


Chapter 6 Dr Jacques Benveniste:
The case of the missing energy

Chapter 7 Clinical Ecology:
Stratagem for a poisoned world

Chapter 8 Dr William Rea:
Clinical ecologist

Chapter 9 Dr Jean Monro:
Clinical ecologist

Chapter 10 Bristol Cancer Help Centre

Chapter 11 Industrial food and nutritional medicine

Chapter 12 Dr Stephen Davies:
Nutritional doctor

Chapter 13 Patrick Holford:
The Institute for Optimum Nutrition

Chapter 14 Belinda Barnes and Foresight:
Nutrition for two

Chapter 15 Robert Woodward and Rita Greer:
Larkhall

Chapter 16 AIDS: the plague that made millions.
Cass Mann, Stuart Marshall, Positively Healthy, Alan Beck and the Pink Paper

Photographs Dr Jacques Benveniste / Dr Jean Monro Pat Pilkington and Penny Brohn Dr Stephen Davies / Patrick Holford Belinda Barnes / Robert Woodward and Rita Greer / Cass Mann.

 

PART THREE

THE STANDING ARMIES OF SCIENCE: BRITAIN

A campaign in defence of science, similar to that in America, has gone on in Britain for some time. Organizations with 'special relationship' links, have exchanged ideas about campaigning with American organizations. The Rationalist Press Association is one of the oldest English humanist organizations; it is linked to the American Humanist Association from which CSICOP grew. The British and Irish Skeptic was a magazine launched by U.K Skeptics, a small pro-science group set up by the British branch of CSICOP. The last three chapters of this part look at British science and industry lobby groups, associated with food, pharmaceuticals and industrial science. Chapter 20 introduces the Wellcome Foundation and discusses the connection of this transatlantic pharmaceutical company with the health fraud movement and the British government.

Chapter 17 The Rationalist Press Association

Chapter 18 British and Irish Skeptics

Chapter 19 From the table to the grave:
The British Nutrition Foundation

Chapter 20 Wellcome, Part One:
A powerful concern

Chapter 21 The pollution of science
 


PART FOUR

THE BRITISH CAMPAIGN AGAINST HEALTH FRAUD

The British Campaign Against Health Fraud (CAHF) was launched early in 1989; it had links with many of the organizations already described. CAHF was set up by Caroline Richmond, a medical journalist, and drew together a number of doctors, practitioners and journalists who had often expressed views sympathetic to the pharmaceutical industry, the food industry or science. The one 'outsider' who was to speak in empathy with the Campaign was Duncan Campbell, a left of centre investigative journalist. Chapter 28 analyses Campbell's changing perspective, which coincided with the beginning of the Concorde trials for the Wellcome AIDS drug AZT.

Chapter 22 Wellcome, Part Two:
Developing and marketing AZT

Chapter 23 Wellcome, Part Three:
AZT, the domestic market

Chapter 24 Caroline Richmond, Part One:
The chemical agent

Chapter 25 Caroline Richmond, Part Two:
The Richmond way

Chapter 26 The Campaign Against Health Fraud,
Part One: Background and beginnings

Chapter 27 The Campaign Against Health Fraud,
Part Two: Early targets

Chapter 28 Dr Vincent Marks:
The company director

Chapter 29 Duncan Campbell:
Sewers surveyed

Chapter 30 Professor Michael Baum:
The trials of a cancer doctor

Chapter 31 The Campaign Against Health Fraud, Part Three: The players and the game 1989 - 1991

 

PART FIVE

OVER THE TOP: BATTLES AND SKIRMISHES AFTER 1989

The last part of the book picks up the stories of the practitioners whose early careers and ways of working were examined in Part Two. After the setting up of the CAHF in 1989, all these people, together with a number of others, working mainly in the field of immunology, found themselves under constant attack, in the media and within professional organizations. By the use of a battery of prosecuting agencies and propaganda techniques a large group of practitioners and commentators were criminalised. There were substantial similarities between these attacks and the ones which were being carried out in America.

Photographs Jabar Sultan/Philip Barker/
Jad Adams/Dr Leslie Davis/Elizabeth
Marsh Yves Delatte/Sandra Goodman/Dr Mumby.

Chapter 32 Wellcome, Part Four:
Colonising the voluntary sector

Chapter 33 Fighting the invisible agenda
" Jad Adams. Brian Deer.
Cass Mann. Positively Healthy
Alan Beck. The Pink Paper

Chapter 34 Trials of strength:
Knocking out the opposition
" Joan Shenton and Meditel
" Dr Sharp, Jabar Sultan, Philip Barker
" Dr Roger Chalmers, Dr Leslie Davis
" Yves Delatte, Sandra Goodman, Monica Bryant
" Elizabeth Marsh

Chapter 35 The assault on the Breakspear Hospital
" Lorraine Hoskin. Dr Monro.
" Lorraine Taylor. Liza Ensen.
" Dr Freed. Dr Mumby

Chapter 36 Mugging the cancer patients
" Bristol Cancer Help Centre

Chapter 37 Attacking healthy nutrition
" Stephen Davies. Patrick Holford. Belinda Barnes. Rita Greer and
Robert Woodward

Chapter 38 Conclusions


Chapter references
Bibliography
List of British and American self-help organizations
Index

 

 

click here to download and purchase Dirty Medicine e-book

 

click here to read about Martin Walker and his work.

 

 

 


home | about | magazines | articles | news | order form | links | site history